XLFeet Reviews

XLFeet has an overall rating of 1.8 based on 17 reviews. Customer feedback on XLFeet is mixed.

1.8/5.0

17 reviews

5 Stars

0

4 Stars

1

3 Stars

4

2 Stars

3

1 Star

9

All XLFeet Reviews (17)
RamblinMan
November 10, 2026
"Would Never Use Them Again-Strict Policies"

I purchased two pairs of identical Drew boots from XLFeet, differing only in color. One pair was fine, but the other had what appeared to be a manufacturing defect that significantly affected the comfort of the boots.

XLFeet submitted a warranty claim to Drew, which was approved. XLFeet made obtaining that approval sound unusually difficult, although my previous experience dealing directly with Drew on a warranty claim was prompt, straightforward, and resulted in a refund to my original payment method.

Despite the approved warranty claim, XLFeet refused to refund my $170.95, insisting that its policy permitted only replacement or store credit.

XLFeet did offer a replacement, explaining that it had one remaining pair of the same discontinued boots in stock. However, neither XLFeet nor Drew had physically inspected the defective pair, and XLFeet acknowledged that neither could determine whether the problem was unique to my particular pair. I did not want to risk receiving another pair with the same potential defect, only to find myself still limited to store credit rather than a refund.

XLFeet also insisted that I had agreed to its return policy when purchasing. Yet I found that customers could complete checkout without ever seeing or affirmatively acknowledging the restrictive defective-merchandise provisions, which were located within a separate Refund Policy page. I only became aware of those restrictions after XLFeet refused my refund request.

What bothered me most was the company's rigid approach. Rather than agreeing to what I considered a reasonable solution—a refund for a manufacturer-approved warranty claim—and retaining a customer, XLFeet seemed more interested in defending the fine print of a policy it created and winning a protracted debate over that policy. Customers should understand that XLFeet's warranty remedies are more restrictive than those I experienced when purchasing directly from Drew.

Ultimately, I disputed the charge with my credit card company. After a two-month investigation, the issuer resolved the dispute in my favor and made my $170.95 credit permanent.

XLFeet may have defended its policy, but it lost a customer in the process. I won't purchase from them again.

jacob_Roberts83
May 21, 2026
"Shipping sure ain't cheap"
I was ready to order, but the shipping cost was just way too high. It ain't not a small fee either, so it kind of made me second-guess the whole purchase.
marsha1974
May 21, 2026
"Mostly right, but a little annoying"
My order from xlfeet.com showed up in a decent amount of time, and most of it was exactly what I ordered. One pair came in the wrong color, though, which was kind of frustrating. The size was right and the other items were fine, so it wasn’t a huge deal, but it still meant extra hassle. Compared to a few other shoe sites I’ve used, the shipping was about average, but I’ve had fewer mix-ups elsewhere. I’d probably order again, but I’d definitely double-check everything as soon as it arrives...
john1970
May 16, 2026
"Shipping felt a little slow"
It took a bit longer than I was expecting, not sure how to explain it, but it just felt kind of slow. The shoes did show up in good condition though, so no issues there
william_Parker03
May 13, 2026
"Great shoes, but the mobile site needs work"
I found the shoes I was looking for, which was great, and a friend had actually recommended the site to me. But using it on my phone was a little frustrating. Some pages took a while to load, and the filters didn’t always save the options I had selected.
Checkout was also kind of clunky on mobile. I had to backtrack a few times, which got annoying quickly. Overall, it wasn’t a terrible experience, but the site could definitely be smoother and easier to use on a phone.
EstherBrown
May 01, 2026
"Sizing felt a bit off"
Well... I was hoping these would fit a little better, but they ended up feeling too wide on my feet. They might work for someone with a wider fit, but they just weren’t quite right for me
ArturoMassie_88
March 17, 2026
"Finally found some decent big-size options"
I had a good experience shopping on xlfeet.com. I wear a hard-to-find size, so usually I’m stuck scrolling through like one sad-looking pair of shoes and calling it a day. Here I actually had a few options, which was a nice surprise. I was browsing while drinking lukewarm coffee at my kitchen table, so maybe my standards were low, but still, it felt better than most shoe sites. A couple styles I liked were out of stock in my size, which was annoying, but overall it was way less frustrating than usual. I’d use it again...
Glenda_foresta90
February 28, 2026
"I emailed them twice about my order and..."
I emailed them twice about my order and never heard back. i kind of regret ordering from them because it feels like no one is even checking the messages. Really frustrating experience.
hello_marie313
January 25, 2026
"Fell apart after just a couple weeks"
I really wanted to like these shoes, and I wasn’t exactly doing anything rough in them either, just normal everyday wear. But after about two weeks, the sole already started peeling off. I feel like for something brand new, that shouldn’t be happening so fast. I don’t think I’m being too picky here, the quality just wasn’t there.
hongmarsh7959
January 24, 2026
"Not many brands to choose from"
I went on xlfeet.com thinking I’d finally find some bigger-name brands in my size, but the selection was kind of disappointing.

They do have shoes, sure, but if you’re even a little picky about brands, it gets frustrating fast. I kept scrolling and seeing the same few names over and over, while the brands I normally buy were nowhere to be found.
The site itself was easy enough to use, so that wasn’t the problem. It’s just annoying when the shopping part should be the fun part, but the limited brand selection made it hard to actually find anything I wanted to order...
SaraWhaley
January 14, 2026
"Exchange process was way more annoying than it needed to be"
Trying to make an exchange took forever, and getting a straight answer from anyone was like pulling teeth. I kept getting those polished, scripted-sounding replies that don’t actually explain anything, which just made me trust the whole process even less. Eventually it moved along, but it was a hassle from start to finish.
carydavis3057
January 14, 2026
"Good selection, but pricier than I expected"
I ordered from xlfeet.com mainly because they actually had my size, which is usually the hardest part for me when shopping for shoes. I wasn’t expecting anything fancy, just a smooth order, and that’s pretty much what I got. The shoes arrived fine and everything was as described.
The only thing that stood out was the price. I expected bigger sizes to cost a little more, but it still ended up being higher than I hoped. For what I got, the value felt okay, just not amazing.
Overall, it’s a decent site if you need harder-to-find sizes. I wouldn’t call it cheap, but I’d consider ordering again if there was a sale or discount going on
cedric_Whitfield00
January 12, 2026
"Returning my shoes was way more frustrating than it should’ve been"
I tried to return a pair of shoes and the whole process just dragged on forever. Support wasn’t very helpful, it kind of felt like they were blaming me for the issue instead of trying to fix it. It was such a hassle that I don’t think I’ll be ordering from them again
MCKINNEY
January 10, 2026
"I was really hoping these shoes would..."
I was really hoping these shoes would work out, but they didn’t fit the way I expected at all?! Then trying to return them ended up being way more of a hassle than it should’ve been. I waited longer than I hoped, and the customer service didn’t feel all that helpful. i’m disappointed and probably won’t order from xlfeet.com again.
darryl1995
December 27, 2025
"Comfortable enough, but not the best"
The shoes fit fine and feel comfortable for short walks. I wore them out with my sister for the day, though, and by the end my feet were still a bit tired. They’re definitely better than some other pairs I’ve tried, but I was expecting a little more cushion overall
robert1973
December 18, 2025
"Item showed in stock, but it wasn’t"
I placed my order because the site said the item was available, but then I found out nothing was actually in stock. Frustrating, and not a great customer experience
harrycurry2718
December 12, 2025
"Not a lot in wide sizes"
I went in thinking they’d have more wide-width options, but it was kind of disappointing. A bunch of the shoes I actually liked either didn’t come in wide or weren’t available, at least from what I could tell. Maybe I just went at a bad time, but it felt like I didn’t really get anywhere.
Have a question about XLFeet?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.